Proceedings reportedly stalled when the Dutch theologian announced he would not answer questions that might incriminate his theology. GENEVA — The city’s theological council was thrown into confusion this week after Jacobus Arminius, summoned to clarify his teaching on grace and election, abruptly refused to answer a crucial question on the grounds that it might later be used against him. Witnesses say he invoked a mysterious “Fifth Amendment to the Constitution,” a concept which would not exist for several centuries but was nonetheless delivered with great conviction. The hearing began calmly enough. Arminius explained his training in Geneva, his respect for the Reformed confessions, and his desire to avoid presenting God as arbitrary or cruel. He answered detailed questions about sin, Christ’s atonement, and the call to repentance. Tension rose when an examiner asked, “Master Arminius, do you affirm that God’s decree of election is unconditional and particular, as our churches c...