Guests say the annual barbecue took a theological turn after one man explained that freedom is real, but only in the same sense that a dead sinner is “free” to do whatever keeps him dead. PHILADELPHIA — What began as a routine Fourth of July gathering featuring hamburgers, folding chairs, and a gentle misunderstanding of human liberty ended Saturday in a prolonged argument after a cage-stage Calvinist spent the afternoon insisting that Independence Day is a strange time to pretend the will is free. Witnesses said the man first became agitated during a toast to “freedom,” at which point he reportedly stared into the middle distance like someone hearing a hymn sung in the wrong key. He then launched into a lecture about Luther’s Bondage of the Will, Calvin’s Institutes, and Paul’s letter to the Romans, as if the cookout had accidentally become a seminary exam and everyone had failed. “People keep acting like freedom is the default setting,” he said, according to several attendees wh...
Critics say Paul’s Roman passport, Jewish pedigree, and nonstop preaching make him “problematic” at best—and possibly one of those people who thinks Christ outranks the discourse. ROME — Social media users were once again forced into a familiar and exhausting interpretive crisis this week after realizing that the apostle Paul cannot be neatly sorted into the preferred categories of modern ideological panic. The controversy began when several commentators noticed that Paul appealed to his Roman citizenship when it helped him, identified as a Jew when relevant, and still managed to spend the rest of his life announcing that Jesus Christ—not Caesar, not tribe, and not the hot take of the moment—was Lord. This, according to online critics, is exactly the sort of thing that makes someone a Christian nationalist. “He obviously had strong views about identity, authority, and the public square,” said one observer after six consecutive posts that did not survive contact with the text. “That’s t...